How cancelling works in Germany, France and the Netherlands
The EU sets the floor; member states build on it differently. Three of the biggest markets, and the local rule that decides whether you are out.
8 min read
Article 11a is now the same everywhere. Almost nothing else is. These three markets show how wide the spread is.
Germany — the button that must work without logging in
Germany has had a cancellation button since 1 July 2022, under § 312k BGB. Its defining feature is that it must be reachable without an account and without signing in: a visible button, then a confirmation page, then a confirmation you can save. The EU withdrawal function arrives on top of that, implemented through § 356a BGB.
What this means for you: on a German-facing site, look for the cancellation route before you log in. If it only exists inside the account area, that is the problem, not your navigation.
France — the channel you came in by
French rules centre on symmetry of channel. If you subscribed online, you must be able to cancel online, by the same means. A trader cannot route an online sign-up into a postal cancellation.
The Netherlands — the strictest clock
Dutch law is the most specific of the three:
- A subscription that renews in three-month blocks must be cancellable at the end of each block.
- One that continues indefinitely can be cancelled at any time, with one month's notice — three months for infrequently published titles.
- Trial subscriptions to newspapers and magazines cannot be tacitly renewed at all. The trial simply ends; you do not have to cancel it. If the publisher wants you to continue, it has to ask you to take out a new subscription.
- A clause tying you in for another year with no interim exit sits on the statutory black list of unreasonably onerous terms.
Enforcement is real: a Trade and Industry Appeals Tribunal judgment of 1 September 2026 confirms the ACM acts on incorrect renewal and cancellation terms, at substantial cost to the trader.
Belgium, in one line
Where the tacit-renewal rules are breached, the renewal is illegal — you can reclaim what was charged and still walk away.
The pattern
Fixed-term contracts are the hard case everywhere. Leaving one early is generally only possible if the contract says so, and usually at a cost. Indefinite contracts are the easy case. If you have a choice at sign-up, the monthly rolling plan is worth more than its price difference suggests.
| Germany | France | Netherlands | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cancel button | yes, § 312k BGB, no login | same channel as sign-up | — |
| Notice on indefinite | — | — | 1 month |
| Trial auto-renewal | allowed if disclosed | allowed if disclosed | banned for press |
General information, not legal advice. Check the current national text before relying on any of this.
More in Your rights in the EU
The EU cancel button: why making you send an email is now illegal
Since 19 June 2026 every trader selling online to EU consumers must show a working withdrawal button. Here is what it has to look like and what to do when it is missing.
You get one withdrawal window, not two — unless they never told you
The most misunderstood rule in subscriptions: a free trial converting to paid does not restart your 14 days. The exception that gives them back is the part worth knowing.
The cancellation dark patterns that are already illegal in the EU
Confirmshaming, the loop that returns you to the start, the offer you cannot decline without a phone call. Most of it is already covered by existing law.